Best places to eat or drink in Carlisle, PA
Nestled in the Cumberland Valley, Carlisle, Pennsylvania boasts an unusually vibrant food scene for a historic college town. Thanks to the international influences of Dickinson College and the U.S. Army War College, you can walk just a few downtown blocks and sample everything from wood-fired pizzas to hand-pulled ramen.
Whether you’re in town for a car show, visiting Dickinson, or exploring historic downtown, here are the best places to eat or drink in Carlisle PA
1. One13 Social
The Vibe: Modern, upscale-casual, and vibrant.
The Flavor: Global comfort food paired with craft cocktails.
Why Visit: Located right on Hanover Street, One13 Social offers one of the most polished dining experiences in downtown Carlisle. The kitchen puts creative spins on American classics using seasonal, locally sourced ingredients.
Must-Try: The Low Country Shrimp & Grits or the Beet & Burrata salad.
2. Pitt Street Station
The Vibe: Relaxed, vintage-railroad-inspired gastropub.
The Flavor: Elevated comfort food, wood-fired pizzas, and craft beers.
Why Visit: Located on North Pitt Street, this spot offers a casual setting with an inventive menu featuring local ingredients, clever flavor combinations, and a great draft list.
Must-Try: The Burnt Ends Tacos or the "Bluesy Burger" made with local beef, gorgonzola, and bacon jam.
3. 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion
The Vibe: Rustic-chic steakhouse with a nod to local history.
The Flavor: Wood-fired steaks, seafood, and American pub fare.
Why Visit: Named after the historic Western Pennsylvania uprising, this spot is famous for its collection of over 100 whiskeys and bourbon-infused dishes. The stone fireplace and warm wood interior make it ideal for date nights or group dinners.
Must-Try: The Whiskey Rings (onion rings in a whiskey-tempura batter) and any of their wood-fired hand-cut steaks.
4. Issei Noodle
The Vibe: Fast-casual, trendy, and lively.
The Flavor: Asian fusion, ramen, and pho.
Why Visit: Issei Noodle is a staple for local students and families. Specializing in Pacific Rim and Southeast Asian noodle dishes, it’s the best spot in town when you’re craving a hot, comforting bowl of broth on a cool day.
Must-Try: Spicy Tan Tan Ramen or classic Vietnamese Beef Pho.
5. Helena’s Chocolate Café & Crêperie
The Vibe: Charming Parisian-style café.
The Flavor: Sweet and savory crêpes, artisanal chocolates, and espresso.
Why Visit: Perfect for a light lunch, mid-afternoon coffee date, or dessert run. Helena’s makes delicate, authentic french crêpes to order right in front of you.
Must-Try: A savory goat cheese and spinach crêpe followed by a sweet Nutella-banana crêpe and a dark hot chocolate.
6. The Rustic Tavern
The Vibe: Unpretentious, classic American tavern.
The Flavor: Seafood, steaks, and home-style comfort food.
Why Visit: Just a short drive outside the immediate downtown core, the Rustic Tavern has been a local favorite for over 20 years. It’s frequently voted as having the best crab cakes and steaks in Cumberland County.
Must-Try: Their signature Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes.
7. Market Cross Pub & Brewery
The Vibe: Authentic English pub with brick-and-timber decor.
The Flavor: Traditional British tavern food and house-brewed English-style ales.
Why Visit: Operating in Carlisle for decades, Market Cross Pub brewed its own craft beer long before the craft boom took off. It offers a warm, welcoming pub atmosphere with classic comfort food.
Must-Try: Traditional Fish & Chips with tartar sauce and malt vinegar.
8. Spoons Cafe
The Vibe: Casual, cozy, downtown lunch spot.
The Flavor: Gourmet sandwiches, hearty soups, fresh salads, and wraps.
Why Visit: A go-to lunch staple right in downtown Carlisle, Spoons is ideal for grabbing a fresh, quick, and satisfying meal while exploring the shops.
Must-Try: The signature Paninis paired with their daily specialty soup.
9. Fay’s Country Kitchen
The Vibe: No-nonsense, retro diner.
The Flavor: Classic hearty breakfast and American diner lunch.
Why Visit: Fay’s is a Carlisle legend for breakfast lovers. Expect big portions, affordable prices, friendly service, and a line out the door on weekend mornings.
Must-Try: The stuffed French toast or a custom omelet with home fries.
10. Denim Coffee
The Vibe: Clean, modern specialty coffee shop.
The Flavor: Freshly roasted specialty coffee, matcha, smoothies, and breakfast sandwiches.
Why Visit: Located directly on the central square, Denim Coffee roasts its own beans locally. It’s the go-to spot to grab a morning drink before walking through historic Carlisle’s shops and parks.
Must-Try: A pour-over made with single-origin beans paired with a house-made breakfast sandwich.
Comments